Save Money on Subaru Legacy Insurance in Toledo

  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Toledo Auto Insurance
  4. >
  5. Subaru Legacy

If you're searching for lower-cost insurance on the web, are you baffled by the crazy number of insurance choices that you can choose from? There are so many choices available that it can be a challenge to find better premium rates for Subaru Legacy insurance in Toledo. Toledo is a great city to live in, but having to pay for pricey insurance can make it impossible to buy proper levels of coverage.

Insurance rates Subaru Legacy in ToledoInconceivable but true, a large majority of consumers have stayed with the same insurance company for at least the last four years, and nearly 40% of drivers have never shopped around. Most drivers in the U.S. can save approximately $850 each year just by comparing rates, but most undervalue the large savings they would see if they just switched companies.

Buying the cheapest car insurance in Toledo is actually quite easy if you know where to start. Virtually each driver who is required by state law to have car insurance stands a good chance to find lower prices. Although Ohio drivers should learn the way companies determine how much to charge because rates fluctuate considerably.

How to get Toledo Subaru Legacy insurance quotes

When comparing car insurance rates, know that making a lot of price comparisons helps improve the odds of finding a better price.

The companies shown below provide price comparisons in Ohio. If you want to find the best car insurance in Toledo, OH, it's a good idea that you compare several of them to get a more complete price comparison.

Insurance is not optional in Ohio

Even though it can be expensive, insurance is required in Ohio but also provides important benefits.

  • Most states have minimum liability requirements which means it is punishable by state law to not carry specific minimum amounts of liability coverage if you don't want to risk a ticket. In Ohio these limits are 25/50/25 which means you must have $25,000 of bodily injury coverage per person, $50,000 of bodily injury coverage per accident, and $25,000 of property damage coverage.
  • If your Subaru has a loan, most banks will make it mandatory that you have insurance to ensure the loan is repaid in case of a total loss. If you do not pay your insurance premiums, the bank may buy a policy for your Subaru at a significantly higher premium and force you to pay the higher price.
  • Insurance protects both your car and your assets. It will also cover medical bills for not only you but also any passengers injured in an accident. Liability coverage, the one required by state law, will also pay to defend you if you are named as a defendant in an auto accident. If you receive damage to your vehicle caused by a storm or accident, comprehensive (other-than-collision) and collision coverage will pay to repair the damage.

The benefits of carrying adequate insurance are definitely more than the cost, especially when you need to use it. According to a 2015 survey, the average American driver overpays as much as $820 a year so we recommend shopping around each time the policy renews to help ensure money is not being wasted.

Auto insurance data for a Subaru Legacy

The rate table shown next showcases different coverage costs for Subaru Legacy models. Being more informed about how premiums are formulated helps drivers make smart buying decisions.

Subaru Legacy Insurance Rates in Toledo, OH
Model Comp Collision Liability Medical UM/UIM Annual Premium Monthly Premium
Legacy 2.5I $176 $226 $234 $14 $70 $720 $60
Legacy 2.5I Premium $176 $274 $234 $14 $70 $768 $64
Legacy 2.5I Premium $176 $274 $234 $14 $70 $768 $64
Legacy 3.6R Premium $194 $274 $234 $14 $70 $786 $66
Legacy 3.6R $194 $274 $234 $14 $70 $786 $66
Legacy 2.5I Limited $194 $274 $234 $14 $70 $786 $66
Legacy 2.5GT Premium $194 $322 $234 $14 $70 $834 $70
Legacy 3.6R Limited $194 $322 $234 $14 $70 $834 $70
Legacy 2.5 GT Limited $194 $322 $234 $14 $70 $834 $70
Legacy 2.5 GT Limited $194 $322 $234 $14 $70 $834 $70
Legacy 2.5 GT Limited $194 $322 $234 $14 $70 $834 $70
Get Your Own Custom Quote Go

Prices based on single male driver age 40, no speeding tickets, no at-fault accidents, $500 deductibles, and Ohio minimum liability limits. Discounts applied include safe-driver, homeowner, multi-policy, multi-vehicle, and claim-free. Price information does not factor in specific location information which can impact coverage prices considerably.

Rate comparison for different deductibles

One of the hardest decisions when shopping for auto insurance is how high or low should comp and collision deductibles be. The rates below can help you visualize the difference in cost when you select higher and lower policy deductibles. The first rate comparisons uses a $100 deductible and the second set of rates uses a $500 deductible.

Subaru Legacy insurance prices with $100 deductibles
Model Comp Collision Liability Medical UM/UIM Annual Premium Monthly Premium
Legacy 2.5I $246 $290 $192 $12 $58 $823 $69
Legacy 2.5I Premium $246 $352 $192 $12 $58 $885 $74
Legacy 2.5I Premium $246 $352 $192 $12 $58 $885 $74
Legacy 3.6R Premium $270 $352 $192 $12 $58 $909 $76
Legacy 3.6R $270 $352 $192 $12 $58 $909 $76
Legacy 2.5I Limited $270 $352 $192 $12 $58 $909 $76
Legacy 2.5GT Premium $270 $416 $192 $12 $58 $973 $81
Legacy 3.6R Limited $270 $416 $192 $12 $58 $973 $81
Legacy 2.5 GT Limited $270 $416 $192 $12 $58 $973 $81
Legacy 2.5 GT Limited $270 $416 $192 $12 $58 $973 $81
Legacy 2.5 GT Limited $270 $416 $192 $12 $58 $973 $81
Get Your Own Custom Quote Go
Subaru Legacy insurance prices with $500 deductibles
Model Comp Collision Liability Medical UM/UIM Annual Premium Monthly Premium
Legacy 2.5I $180 $196 $192 $12 $58 $638 $53
Legacy 2.5I Premium $180 $238 $192 $12 $58 $680 $57
Legacy 2.5I Premium $180 $238 $192 $12 $58 $680 $57
Legacy 3.6R Premium $198 $238 $192 $12 $58 $698 $58
Legacy 3.6R $198 $238 $192 $12 $58 $698 $58
Legacy 2.5I Limited $198 $238 $192 $12 $58 $698 $58
Legacy 2.5GT Premium $198 $280 $192 $12 $58 $740 $62
Legacy 3.6R Limited $198 $280 $192 $12 $58 $740 $62
Legacy 2.5 GT Limited $198 $280 $192 $12 $58 $740 $62
Legacy 2.5 GT Limited $198 $280 $192 $12 $58 $740 $62
Legacy 2.5 GT Limited $198 $280 $192 $12 $58 $740 $62
Get Your Own Custom Quote Go

Above prices assume married male driver age 30, no speeding tickets, no at-fault accidents, and Ohio minimum liability limits. Discounts applied include claim-free, multi-policy, multi-vehicle, homeowner, and safe-driver. Prices do not factor in the specific area where the vehicle is garaged which can alter premium rates substantially.

Using the data above, we can ascertain that using a $100 deductible will cost you about $18 more each month or $216 each year averaged for all Legacy models than opting for the higher $500 deductible. Since you would pay $400 more to settle a claim with a $500 deductible as compared to a $100 deductible, if you go more than 22 months between claims, you would probably be better off by going with a higher deductible.

How accidents and tickets impact rates

The diagram below illustrates how traffic citations and at-fault accidents can impact Subaru Legacy car insurance rates for different age groups. Data assumes a single female driver, comp and collision included, $250 deductibles, and no discounts are taken into consideration.

Men versus women drivers and insurance cost

The information below visualizes the comparison of Subaru Legacy auto insurance rates for male and female drivers. The prices are based on no accidents or driving violations, full physical damage coverage, $1,000 deductibles, single status, and no discounts are factored in.

Affordable rates with discounts

Companies offering auto insurance don't list every policy discount very well, so below is a list some of the more common in addition to some of the lesser obvious credits available to lower your premiums when you buy Toledo car insurance online.Discount auto insurance

  • First Accident Forgiveness - Not a discount per se, but certain companies permit an accident before hitting you with a surcharge so long as you are claim-free for a specific time period.
  • Early Switch Discount - A few auto insurance companies allow discounts for switching to them before your current expiration date. You may see this discount when you get Toledo car insurance quotes online.
  • E-sign Discounts - Some auto insurance companies will discount your bill up to fifty bucks just for signing your application digitally online.
  • Onboard Data Collection - People who choose to allow driving data submission to analyze driving manner by using a telematic data system such as Drivewise from Allstate or Snapshot from Progressive might see lower rates if they exhibit good driving behavior.
  • Driver's Ed - Make teen driver coverage more affordable by requiring them to participate in a local driver's education class if it's offered in school.
  • No Claim Discounts - Claim-free drivers pay much less compared to bad drivers.
  • Defensive Driver - Passing a defensive driving course can save you 5% or more and make you a better driver.
  • Discount for Life Insurance - Select companies reward you with a discounted auto insurance rate on car insurance if you buy some life insurance in addition to your auto policy.
  • Pay Now and Pay Less - If paying your policy premium upfront as opposed to paying monthly you can actually save on your bill.
  • Theft Prevention System - Cars and trucks equipped with anti-theft or alarm systems are stolen less frequently and qualify for as much as a 10% discount.

While discounts sound great, it's important to understand that most credits do not apply to your bottom line cost. A few only apply to individual premiums such as liability and collision coverage. So when the math indicates all the discounts add up to a free policy, company stockholders wouldn't be very happy.

The chart below illustrates the difference between Subaru Legacy insurance rates with and without discounts applied. The premium estimates are based on a female driver, a clean driving record, no at-fault accidents, Ohio state minimum liability limits, comprehensive and collision coverage, and $1,000 deductibles. The first bar for each age group shows premium with no discounts. The second shows the rates with multi-car, safe-driver, multi-policy, homeowner, claim-free, and marriage discounts applied.

Large auto insurance companies and a summarized list of policyholder discounts can be found below.

  • State Farm may offer discounts for passive restraint, good student, anti-theft, driver's education, good driver, and multiple autos.
  • Farmers Insurance discounts include youthful driver, business and professional, teen driver, alternative fuel, homeowner, bundle discounts, and early shopping.
  • GEICO may have discounts that include good student, driver training, air bags, five-year accident-free, and multi-policy.
  • American Family policyholders can earn discounts including air bags, good driver, good student, TimeAway discount, and Steer into Savings.
  • Nationwide offers discounts including anti-theft, family plan, multi-policy, Farm Bureau membership, and accident-free.
  • Progressive may include discounts for multi-vehicle, online quote discount, good student, continuous coverage, multi-policy, and online signing.

If you want affordable Toledo car insurance quotes, ask all companies you are considering to give you their best rates. All car insurance discounts might not be available to policyholders in your area. To locate providers with the best Subaru Legacy insurance discounts in Toledo, click here.

Insurance agents near you

Certain consumers still like to visit with an insurance agent and that can be a smart move A nice benefit of comparing auto insurance online is you can get cheap auto insurance rates and still choose a local agent.

After completing this simple form, your insurance data is sent to agents in your area who will give you bids for your business. You won't need to find an agent as quotes are delivered to your email. It's the lowest rates and a licensed agent to talk to. In the event you want to compare rates from a specific auto insurance provider, just find their quoting web page and complete a quote there.

Finding the right company is decision based upon more than just the quoted price. These are some questions your agent should answer.

  • Can glass claims be handled at your home?
  • What insurance companies do they work with in Toledo?
  • Do they have designations such as AIC, CPCU, or CIC?
  • Is working in the agency their full-time job?
  • How are they compensated?
  • When do they do policy reviews?

Multiple types of car insurance agents in Toledo

If you are searching for local Toledo agents, you must know there are a couple different types of agents and how they work. Auto insurance agents are either exclusive or independent.

Exclusive Agencies

Exclusive agencies can only provide one company's prices like State Farm, Allstate, and Farm Bureau. They are unable to provide prices from multiple companies so you might not find the best rates. They are very knowledgeable on the products they sell which helps them sell insurance even at higher premiums. Drivers often buy from the same agent for years partially due to loyalty to the company rather than having low rates.

Below are Toledo exclusive agents that can give you price quote information.

View more agents

Independent Agents

These agents do not write with just one company so they can insure your vehicles with any number of different companies and find you cheaper rates. If you are not satisfied with one company, they can switch companies in-house and you don't have to switch agencies. When shopping rates, it's recommended you get rate quotes from independent agents in order to have the best price comparison. A lot of them also have access to additional companies that you may not be familiar with that many times have cheaper rates.

The following is a short list of independent insurance agencies in Toledo that are able to give price quote information.


  • 4149 N Holland Sylvania Rd #3 - Toledo, OH 43623 - (419) 882-1770 - View Map
  • Fox Insurance
    4560 Heatherdowns Blvd # 103 - Toledo, OH 43614 - (419) 385-2797 - View Map
  • Detlef Insurance
    833 Woodville Rd - Toledo, OH 43605 - (419) 693-7458 - View Map

View more agents

When to get professional advice

Always keep in mind that when comparing coverage for your vehicles, there is no one size fits all plan. Every situation is different and your policy should reflect that.Higher deductibles save money These are some specific questions can help discover if your situation would benefit from an agent's advice.

  • Should I buy more coverage than the required Ohio minimum liability coverage?
  • When can I cancel my policy?
  • Does my Subaru Legacy qualify for pleasure use?
  • Does my medical payments coverage pay my health insurance deductible?
  • How does medical payments coverage work?
  • Do I need medical payments coverage since I have good health insurance?
  • Will I be non-renewed for getting a DUI or other conviction?
  • How much cheaper are high deductibles?
  • Is rental equipment covered for theft or damage?
  • Is my Subaru Legacy covered if I use it for business?

If it's difficult to answer those questions but you know they apply to you then you might want to talk to a licensed insurance agent. To find an agent in your area, complete this form or you can go here for a list of companies in your area.

One last thing to lower rates

While you're price shopping online, never skimp on critical coverages to save a buck or two. There are too many instances where drivers have reduced uninsured motorist or liability limits only to discover later that it was a big error on their part. The goal is to purchase a proper amount of coverage at the best price but still have enough coverage for asset protection.

Discount Subaru Legacy insurance in Toledo can be purchased on the web and from local insurance agents, and you need to comparison shop both so you have a total pricing picture. Some companies may not provide rates over the internet and usually these small insurance companies sell through independent insurance agencies.

Steps to buying lower priced Subaru Legacy insurance in Toledo

The best way to find better pricing on car insurance rates is to compare quotes annually from companies in Toledo. You can compare prices by completing these steps.

  • First, spend some time learning about what is in your policy and the measures you can take to lower rates. Many policy risk factors that increase rates such as speeding tickets, careless driving and a less-than-favorable credit history can be eliminated by making lifestyle changes or driving safer.
  • Second, compare prices from direct, independent, and exclusive agents. Direct companies and exclusive agencies can only give rate quotes from a single company like Progressive or Allstate, while independent agencies can provide price quotes from many different companies. Compare rates now
  • Third, compare the new rate quotes to your existing policy to see if switching to a new carrier will save money. If you can save some money, make sure the effective date of the new policy is the same as the expiration date of the old one.
  • Fourth, give notification to your agent or company of your intention to cancel your current auto insurance policy. Submit a signed application and payment for the new policy. Once coverage is bound, keep the new proof of insurance certificate with your registration paperwork.

The key aspect of shopping around is to try to use similar deductibles and liability limits on each price quote and and to get prices from as many companies as feasibly possible. Doing this helps ensure a fair rate comparison and a thorough price selection.

More tips and info about car insurance is available in the articles below: